01993 894 700

Talk to us to help save yourself time & money

My contractor has insurance. Isn’t that enough?

3 minutes

One of the most common conversations I have with clients planning a renovation starts with this statement: 'Don't worry, my builder has insurance’.

In many cases, they're surprised when I explain that this doesn't necessarily mean their project is fully protected.

Over the years, I've spoken to homeowners undertaking everything from modest extensions to substantial renovations, and one misconception comes up time and time again. Clients often assume that if the property is insured and the contractor has insurance in place, every aspect of the project is covered.

Unfortunately, that isn't always the case.

Recently, I spoke to a homeowner undertaking a substantial renovation project. The property had a rebuild cost of around £1 million and the building works were valued at approximately £500,000.

The client was comfortable that the existing structure was insured and that their contractor had cover in place. What they hadn't considered was what would happen if the property suffered a major loss towards the end of the project.

By that stage, much of the £500,000 contract value had already been built into the property. If the works themselves weren't insured and a major loss occurred, those costs could need to be incurred all over again.

It's a situation I encounter more often than you might expect, and it highlights one of the most misunderstood aspects of renovation insurance. The starting point is understanding how your existing home insurance will respond once works begin.

Tell your insurer before work begins

When you are planning a renovation, extension or other building work, it is important to check how your home insurance will respond before the project begins.

Most home insurance policies contain conditions relating to building works and it's important to check whether your insurer needs to be notified. Failing to disclose a renovation project could affect how your policy responds in the event of a claim.

Look for references to building works, renovations, structural alterations, contractors or builders within your policy wording. Many Private Client policies will accommodate works up to a specified value, but this often varies between insurers.

In recent years, rising construction costs have meant that projects can exceed these limits more easily than homeowners expect. Where this happens, an insurer may decline to cover the works, continue cover for the existing structure whilst excluding the works themselves, or require alternative arrangements to be put in place.

The difference between insuring your home and insuring the works

One of the most important distinctions is between:

  • The existing structure, which is your home as it stood before the project began

  • The contract works, which includes the work, materials, fixtures and fittings being added as the project progresses

Buildings-only cover may protect the existing structure, but it does not necessarily cover the value of the work completed during the renovation.

For example, imagine that your home has a rebuild cost of £1 million and you are undertaking £500,000 of building works. Towards the end of the project, much of that £500,000 may already have been spent on labour, materials and new installations.

If there is then a major fire or flood and the works are not insured, the buildings policy may reinstate the property as it stood before the renovation began. However, the value of the completed works may not be covered.

In simple terms, your insurer may put you back in the position you were in before the project started, but you could still be left paying for the renovation work all over again.

But my contractor has insurance

A contractor will usually have their own insurance, but this does not automatically mean that your home or the building works are fully protected.

The contractor’s liability insurance will generally only become relevant if the contractor is responsible for the damage and their liability can be established. It may not respond to an event that was unrelated to their work.

Imagine there is a fire at the property, but it was not caused by the contractor or the renovation. Your buildings insurer may reinstate the home as it was before work began, but the contractor’s liability policy may not pay for the completed works because the contractor was not at fault.

There may also be uncertainty over precisely what the contractor’s policy covers, whether its conditions have been met and who controls the claim.

So, when your builder says, “Don’t worry, I have insurance,” the important question is: who is insuring the existing structure, who is insuring the works in progress, and are there any gaps between the two?

Consider your liability exposures

Depending on how the project is structured and your own level of involvement, you may also need to consider liability insurance. For example, if you employ tradespeople directly or take an active role in managing the works, Employers’ Liability Insurance and Project Public Liability Insurance may be required.

Where the project is being managed by a main contractor, your liability exposure may be more limited and Property Owner’s Liability Insurance may be sufficient. However, the appropriate cover will depend on the contractual arrangements and responsibilities involved, so it’s important to seek advice before work begins.

How Howden can help

If there's one thing I've learned from helping clients through renovation projects, it's that assumptions can be expensive. Don't assume your contractor's insurance protects your project, and don't assume your existing home policy covers the works. Taking advice before the first brick is laid can make all the difference if something goes wrong.

The issue I've focused on here is one of the most common gaps I encounter when speaking to homeowners. However, it's not the only consideration. Larger renovation projects can introduce a range of other insurance considerations, from liability exposures to contractual insurance requirements. If you'd like to learn more, we've covered these in our article, Insuring building works on your high-value home.

The earlier these conversations happen, the easier it is to identify potential gaps in cover and ensure your project is protected from start to finish.

If you are planning a renovation, extension or conversion, please call 020 8256 4901 or email privateclients@howdeninsurance.co.uk

Related Products

Construction & Renovation Insurance
Construction and renovation insurance that leaves no stone unturned

Our goal is to help our clients find flexible insurance policies which cover all aspects of construction and renovation.

Insuring building works on your high value home